Brazil – who to blame?

If I hadn’t seen it, I wouldn’t believe it but sure enough, Brazil really did lose 7-1 to Germany last night. But the question on most people’s lips is not ‘how great were Germany?’ but ‘who is to blame for Brazil?’.

Firstly, I think to an extent this is like any match with a huge scoreline – a freak event. German goals 2, 3, 4 and 5 came in such quick succession that after the second, Brazil’s heads seemed to go and there was no way back, Germany being stereotypically clinical in their finishing. A large amount of blame should also go to Scolari for setting up his team in a way that left them exposed and impotent and for failing to change it once Germany started scoring. Also, in hindsight, his squad selection was poor; once Neymar was gone, they had virtually no attacking threat at all. But onto the goals themselves…

Goal 1: Corner, good move by Germany to block off Mueller’s marker, David Luiz should have been tighter which might have helped, but it’s the type of goal that could happen to anyone. One of the other defenders should have peeled off the player they were marking to take Mueller. Blame: Partly Luiz, mostly the rest of the Brazilian defensive unit.

Goal 2: Mueller makes a run in from the German right, played onside by Marcelo who followed him, the rest of the defence seemed to switch off and failed to follow the ball in. Blame: Partly Marcelo, mostly rest of the defence.

Goal 3: Cross from the German right, which could have been stopped by Marcelo being in a defensive position to stop the cross but that rarely happens. Maicon drifts too centrally, almost stepping on David Luiz’s toes at one point, Luiz forced to go even more centrally, leaving Kroos free to run onto the cross on the right. Blame: Partly Marcelo, partly Maicon.

Goal 4: Fernandinho caught in possession, David Luiz and Luis Gustavo (I think) playing RCB and LCB as the full-backs are so high up the pitch but neither reacts to Fernandinho being hassled. Luiz trots back, as if it’s not his job, Germany score. Blame: Small part Fernandinho, partly Luis Gustavo, more so David Luiz.

Goal 5: David Luiz runs up to make a tackle which he looks to jump out of, Germany break through and score again. Blame: Partly David Luiz, partly Brazilian full-backs for not being there, partly midfield 3 for not covering.

Goal 6: Brazil back-line deep, Marcelo absent, cross comes in and Schurrle pops up in space to score. Blame: Marcelo for not stopping the cross, not that he ever does, midfield 3 for not picking Schurrle up.

Goal 7: David Luiz out of position and can’t catch the running Schurrle who scores arguably the only good goal of the match. Blame: Partly David Luiz, partly, arguably, midfield 3 for not covering, but it was an astonishingly good/lucky finish.

Basically, the whole team played badly and the tactics were wrong, but this is where I would apportion the blame for each individual goal.

What do you think? Do you agree? Disagree? Comment below or get me on Twitter @ETNAR_uk

Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s